THE RHETORIC OF RIGHTS IN THE UK CHRISTIAN CHURCHES REGARDING NON-HETEROSEXUAL CITIZENSHIP

  • Stephen J. Hunt

Abstract

One of the major deliberations, indeed source of conflict, within and between Christian churches across the globe is what might be termed the ‘gay debate’. This debate is not merely related to the legitimacy of civil marriages, gay clergy, alongside the broader issue of the citizenship and well-being of gay people within the churches, but has expanded to embrace other forms of non-heterosexuality, including bi-sexuality and transgenderism/sexuality and issues regarding their natures. The debate has also been impacted by matters of secular civil rights and the human rights upon which they are contingent. Christian churches, alongside additional faith communities, are now forced to confront legislation that increasingly sanctions matters of citizenship and equality for non-heterosexual people in the wider social context. This paper considers the major Christian debates in the UK and how both those sympathetic to the cause of gay rights and those opposed are forced to integrate the rhetoric of rights into their respective platforms. Analysis includes examination of the contestation between those advancing such rights on the one hand, and those who oppose them on the basis of religious morality and conscience, in short, religious rights, on the other.

Keywords: Christianity, Churches, Human Rights, LGBT Politics, Moral campaigns

References

Calvert, Simon. 1994. Southwark Welcomes Gay Celebrations: Blasphemy, the Church of England and the LGBT, The Christian Institute New Digest, 4 (1): 4.
Chower, Eyal. 2002. The Physiology of the Citizen: The Present-centered Body and its Political Exile, Political Theory, 30 (5), October: 649-76.
Clark, Victoria. and Finlay, Sara-Jane. 2004. ‘For Better or Worse?’ Lesbian and Gay Marriage, Feminism & Psychology, 14 (1), February: 41-46.
Daum, Werner. 2001. Universalism and the West, Harvard International Review, 23 (2), http://hir.harvard.edu/index.php?page=article&id=909&p=
Davies, Christie and Hunt, Stephen. 1999. Religious Resistance to Secular Moral Permissiveness. Paper presented at the Politics and Religion Conference, Lincoln Theological Institute, February 12.
Dawson, Graham. 2005. Sexual orientation discrimination, Equal Opportunities International, 24 (3-4): 46-9.
De Jong, Dennis. 2008. The Legal Obligations of State and Non-State Actors in Respect of the Protection of Freedom of Thought, Conscience and Religion or Belief’,
Religion and Human Rights, 3 (1), March: 1-13.
Doe, Norman. and Sandberg, Russell. 2007. Religious Exemptions in Discrimination Law, Cambridge Law Journal, 6 (2): 302-12.
Eade, Deborah, Cornwall, Andrea, Correa, Sonia and Jolly, Susie. 2009. Development with a Body: Sexuality, Human Rights and Development, Development in Practice, 19 (1): 126-27.
Franke, Katherine, M. 2006. The Politics of Same-Sex Marriage Politics, Columbia Journal of Gender and Law, 15 (1): 236-48.
Gill, Sean. 1989. The Lesbian and Gay Christian Movement. Cassell, London.
Hunt, Stephen. 2009. Human Rights and Moral Wrongs: The Christian ‘Gay Debate’ in the Secular Sphere, in S. Hunt (ed), Contemporary Christianity and LGBT Sexualities. Ahsgate, Farnham: Hunter, James. 1991. Culture Wars: The Struggle to Define America. Basic Books, New York.
Lyon, David. 2000. Jesus in Disneyland: Religion in Postmodern Times. Polity Press, Cambridge.
Nugent, Robert and Gramwick, Jeannine. 1989. Homosexuality: Protestant, Catholic and Jewish: A Fishbone’s Tale, in R. Husbany (ed), Homosexuality and Religion. Harworth Press, New York.
Percy, Martyn. 2005. Engaging with Contemporary Culture: Christianity, Theology and the Concrete Church. Ashgate, Farnham.
Plummer, Ken. 2003. Intimate Citizenship. University of Washington Press, Seattle.
Saunders, Douglas. 2002. Human Rights and Sexual Orientation in International Law, International Journal of Public Administration, 25 (1): 13-41.
Skogly, Sigrun I. 2001. Crimes Against Humanity - Revisited: Is There a Role for Economic and Social Rights?, The International Journal of Human Rights, 5 (1): 58- 80.
Spitzer, Robert. 2003. Can Some Gay Men and Lesbians Change their Sexual Orientation?, Archives of Sexual Behaviour, 32 (5): 403-17.
Thamidjis, Phillip. 2005. Sexuality and International Human Rights Law, Journal of Homosexuality, 48 (3): 9-29.
Thompson, William. 1997. Charismatic Politics: The Social and Political Impact of Renewal, in S. Hunt, M. Hamilton & T. Walter (eds), Charismatic Christianity: Sociological Perspectives, McMillan, Basingstoke.
Turner, Bryan. 1995. Introduction: Rights and Communities: Prolegomenon to a Sociology of Rights, ‘Symposium: Human rights and the sociological project, Journal of Sociology, 31, January, 1-8.
Published
2017-01-11
Section
TOPIC OF THIS ISSUE