• Jerold Waltman The Baylor University, Texas, USA


How much autonomy should religious institutions have when they employ paid staff? This paper lays out two contrasting models, blanket liberalism and liberal pluralism, that come into play in this area. It then examines in some detail how Parliament dealt with the issue as it considered the Equality Act 2010, especially as the law pertained to sexual orientation. Although the Labour government would have liked to have pushed the country more toward blanket liberalism, in the end it left the law as it was, which was a victory, for the moment at least, for those churches who wished to retain their present degree of autonomy.

Keywords: equality, sexual orientation, employment, church autonomy, United Kingdom


Adhar, Rex and Leigh, Ian. 2005. Religious Freedom in the Liberal State. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Allen, Chris. 2010. Fear and Loathing: The Political Discourse in Relation to Muslims and Islam in the British Contemporary Setting, Politics and Religion Journal, 4 (2).
Barry, Brian. 2001. Culture and Equality: An Egalitarian Critique of Multiculturalism. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA USA.
Bouchard, Daniel. 2009. A Little Bit Against Discrimination? CARE, London.
British Broadcasting Corporation. 2010. Pope Benedict Attacks Government over Equality Bill, 2 February.
Carmelo, Danis. 2011. How Far Can the European Court of Human Rights Go in the Fight against Discrimination? Defining New Standards in its Nondiscrimination
Jurisprudence, International Journal of Constitutional Law, 9 (3-4).
Cohn, Magrit. 2010. Legal Transplant Chronicles: The Evolution of Unreasonableness and Proportionality Review in the Administration in the United
Kingdom, American Journal of Comparative Law, 58 (3).
Discrimination Law Review. 2007. A Framework for Fairness: Proposals for a Single Equality Bill for Great Britain.
Equalities Review. 2007. Fairness and Freedom: The Final Report of the Equalities Review.
Equality and Human Rights Commission. 2009. Human Rights in Britain since the Human Rights Act 1998: A Critical Review.
European Council. 2000. Directive 2000/78.
Galston, William. 2002. Liberal Pluralism: The Implications of Value Pluralism for Political Theory and Practice. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Hirsch, Afua. 2010. Equality Bill: Churches and Campaigners Demand Clarity on Religious Exemption, Guardian, 25 January.
Hunt, Stephen. 2010. The Rhetoric of Rights in the UK Christian Churches Regarding Non-Heterosexual Citizenship, Politics and Religion Journal, 4 (2).
Hunt, Stephen. Forthcoming. Negotiating Equality in the Equality Act (United Kingdom): Church-State Relations in a Post-Christian Society.
Joint Committee on Human Rights. 2009. Legislative Scrutiny: Equality Bill.
Joint Committee on Human Rights. 2010. Legislative Scrutiny: Equality Bill (Second Report).
Labour Party. 2005. Britain Forward Not Back.
Masterman, Roger. 2011. The Separation of Powers in the Contemporary Constitution: Judicial Competence and Independence in the United Kingdom. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
McCrudden, Christopher. 2011. Multiculturalism, Freedom of Religion, Equality and the British Constitution: The JFS Case Considered, International Journal
of Constitutional Law, 9 (1).
McLean, Ian and Peterson, Scot. 2011. Entrenching the Establishment Clause and Free Exercise of Religion in the Written U.K. Constitution, International
Journal of Constitutional Law, 9 (1).
McLean, Iain and Peterson, Scot. 2010. Secularity and Secularism in the United Kingdom: On the Way to the First Amendment, Brigham Young University Law
Review, 2011 (Special Issue).
Norton, Philip. 2011. The British Polity. 5th ed. Longman, Boston.
Samuels, Leslie. 2005. Sexual Orientation Discrimination and the Church: Balancing Competing Human Rights, Ecclesiastical Law Journal, 8 (1).
Sandberg, Russell and Doe, Norman. 2007. Religious Exemptions in Discriminatio Law, Cambridge Law Journal, 66 (2).
Tomes, Laura. 2010. Blasphemy and the Negotiation of Religious Pluralism in Britain, Politics and Religion Journal, 4 (2).
Vickers, Lucy. 2008. Religious Freedom, Religious Discrimination, and the Workplace. Hart Publishing, Oxford.
Woolcock, Nicola. 2007. Youth Worker Wins Gay Job Rights Claim against Bishop, The Times, 19 June